SUPERGIRL (2026) is not great. I would go so far as to say it's not good. This is a shame because I genuinely loved the Superman reboot and most of the spinoff media by James Gunn like Peacemaker and the Creature Commandos. Basically, this movie struggles to settle on a tone and when it does settle on a tone, it doesn't really seem to work very well for the character of Supergirl. I never read WOMAN OF TOMORROW so maybe I'm missing out on something with the adaptation but the simple fact is that I am judging the movie on the basis of its own merits. It's not terrible but if I were to rate it, it would be a three star at max and more like two and a half stars.
The premise is that Kara Zor-El (Milly Alcock) is a drunk survivor of Krypton (technically Argo) that lives her life moving from bar to bar in order to drown out the memories of her homeworld. She has no interest in being a hero as far as I can tell and is comforted only by her dog, Krypto. A young girl, Ruthye (Eve Ridley), comes to her after a bar fight with a request to help her get revenge on the evil Krem (Matthias Schoenaerts). Along the way, they run into Lobo (Jason Momoa) and there are shenanigans until they finally dismantle Krem's human (alien) trafficking business.
This movie is a mess. I'm not one of those internet guys who goes into things trying to hate them and I am generally overly positive about things in fact. I tried to defend Bloodlines 2 for Caine's sake. But if I were to describe the plot of the movie, it is one part True Grit, one part John Wick, and one part Taken with the veneer of Guardians of the Galaxy. To explain why these things don't go together, True Grit is about a revenge story where the revenge is meaningless, Taken is about killing a bunch of Eastern European sex traffickers, John Wick is about avenging man's best friend, and the Guardians of the Galaxy movies are wacky crime dramas. All of these are good movies but none of them make sense when mushed together.
To explain what I mean, True Grit is about a young girl who obsesses over the man who murdered her father even though its fairly clear he's going to die one way or the other. John Wick is about revenge as emotional catharsis over an innocent animal dying. Taken is about punishing people who have committed horrific atrocities that we like seeing get dismantled. Ruthye wants revenge and Kara thinks that's bad but Krem is an irredeemable monster who continues to commit atrocities left and right throughout the movie. Kara wants to save Krypto after he's poisoned but seems bored versus desperate and never seems to think about how she's running out of time.
There's a lot of things that would have been more interesting than Supergirl just going from planet to planet looking for the Brigands (great name, real original). The flashbacks to where Supegirl is on Argo are the best parts of the movie and it would have been fantastic to see her adjusting to Earth as well as talking with Clark about how she doesn't "want" to fit in our small blue planet. Instead, their biggest scene together is one where he doesn't speak Kryptonian and she doesn't speak English. Doesn't he have robots for this? An app on his phone? He understood Kryptonian in the previous movie, he just didn't have the other part of the message.
Jason Momoa is also not a cameo but not really in the movie either. A better writer, not saying me but me and I'm a journeyman at best, would have had Supergirl as an idealist who wants to bring Krem to justice via the Green Lantern Corp's science cells while Lobo wants to kill him for the cash reward from his victims. You could have them play angel and demon on Ruthye's shoulders but Supergirl barely cares and thinks Krem should die herself but a child shouldn't be the one to do him in.
Basically, Supergirl is less Kara Zor-El in this movie and more female Wolverine (which would be X-23 now that I think about it). Krem is also a terrible villain and not just because he feels like someone tried to do Highlander's Kurgan with half the charisma but he doesn't have the power to pose a proper challenge to Kara. This is space, guys, give him strength akin to a Kryptonian or other superpowers. Instead, they just have Kara depowered repeatedly for increasingly dumb reasons. I was also confused by all the Earth music drops since Kara presumably is not familiar with most of these.
In conclusion, I'm glad I saw this movie but it is very flawed. Milly did a great job but I would have preferred a Kara who had a lot of Superman's integrity and heroism. You can do a dark Kara as My Adventures with Superman showed but this one just feels like they missed the El symbol is a symbol for hope. I can't help but think if they'd just had a movie about Kara, Lobo, Krypto, and New Girl hunting the female pirates from midway through the film then it would have been a pretty awesome movie by itself.






















.jpg)
