I have an affection for fighting games which goes back to the Super Nintendo version of Streetfighter 2. The internet has revived much of the joy to be had playing against strangers in arcade games with multiplayer even if design has moved away from being able to sit in front of a TV with friends and multiple controllers. Of course, I've never been terribly good at fighting games since I'm a compulsive button masher. Likewise, I've always wanted more story and more investment in the characters while plenty of gamers I know prefer less (with some wishing there was none at all). Thus, I was a little skeptical anything could make Injustice: Gods Among Us interesting. Then I saw the introduction.
|George Newbern's acting both as "normal" and "crazy" Superman is quite impressive.|
This premise would probably be too dark and a character assassination of Clark Kent if not for the fact we immediately switch to an alternate reality where our heroes are still in existence. Superman's corruption occurred in a parallel reality and "our" heroes are recruited by Batman to take the evil Superman down. Longtime fans of DC comics and their spin-offs will recognize the "Evil DC Superheroes vs. Good Ones" plot as very similar to both the seminal comic series Kingdom Come (though Superman isn't the bad guy there) and the "Justice Lords" episodes of the Justice League cartoon. There's even elements of Mark Waid's Irredeemable.
Some fans have expressed that it's a bit of a cop out to have the renegade Superman not be the 'real' one but I'd argue against this. As much as there's a kind of seedy joy to seeing heroes fall from grace, I'm an optimist in real life and prefer to see good triumph over evil. As such, my chosen character in Injustice: Gods Among Us is Superman and he's going to beat the crap out of the version who disgraced everything he stands for.
|The environments are extremely well-designed.|
The stage design is wonderful, making Metropolis and Gotham City as well as so many other sights evocative. You can fight in the Fortress of Solitude or Bat Cave plus plenty of other recognizable locations. I especially liked the Atlantis, Hall of Justice, and Insurgency stages which really qualify as works of art.
|Harley Quinn makes any game better. So, it gets a +1 just for that.|
My favorite moment in the campaign is when Aquaman from the "normal" universe receives an ultimatum directed at the alternate one to surrender Atlantis. He proceeds to kick the ass of Superman's flunkies (including Captain Marvel) in a truly epic way. I also love Wonder Woman standing up for the true ideals of the Amazons (no matter what DC comics says): peace and justice. The voice actors give it their all and you manage to believe everyone is who they're supposed to be. The fact the game got so many actors famous for doing the characters in other mediums.
This is a work which really "gets" the characters of the DC universe. The moral ambiguity and co-dependency of Harley Quinn, the peaceful warrior credo of Wonder Woman, and Damien Wayne's absurdest need for a father figure who unleashes his dark side are all handled wonderfully. I'm annoyed Supergirl doesn't have a role in the story but, otherwise, I'm impressed by so many characters having cool ties to the new world.
|The gameplay's biggest point? It's fun.|
How good is the plotting in the game? The fact they take the time to explain why Green Arrow can fight Superman in a fist fight along with the Joker. Sure, the excuse amounts to a magic Kryptonian-technology pill which makes people almost as strong as Superman but it works. The fact this excuse shows up in cutscenes is a great little bit of fan continuity which "sells" it to the player. There's a few slow parts in the plot but most of them are quite interesting.
In conclusion, Injustice: Gods Among Us is a great piece of capepunk fiction. Superman's corruption and the toxicity it brings to his fellow heroes is a suitably well-developed tragedy. The fact it isn't, "our" Superman doesn't impact the fact the new world is treated as a valuable and important place in its own right. The fact I was invested in the story from start to finish says its worth getting for those who likes fighting games. If you don't, the storyline is unlikely to change your opinion but this is at the top of storytelling in its genre. With the exception of Arkham Asylum's games, this is probably the best DC comics video game ever made.